Bamboo Scroll竹簡 Ep. 3 · Cut Back the Fiefs
A rebel host in dark banners filling the ground before a great rammed-earth city at dusk, siege walls and mantlets pushed against the lower town, smoke rising along the wall-head, and in the far distance across the open plain a second, silent camp with its ramparts unfinished and no smoke at all
Bamboo Scroll · Han · Episode 3

Cut Back the Fiefs

Wu, Liang and Chang'an, 154 BCE — A minister proposed cutting the great fiefs back and was cut first, still in his court robes, in a marketplace; seven kings rose anyway, and were broken in three months by a commander who would not give battle and would not obey an order to.
18 panels~7 min read free to readevery line sourced
Panel 01: The first month of 154 BCE. The host of Wu and Chu stood before Suiyang, capital of the richest fief in the empire, and had been beating on it for weeks. On the same plain another army was dug in and would not move.
The first month of 154 BCE. The host of Wu and Chu stood before Suiyang, capital of the richest fief in the empire, and had been beating on it for weeks. On the same plain another army was dug in and would not move.
Panel 02: The rebel was sixty-two when he rose, and had been put in his place by the man his father had failed. His father, the founder's elder brother, had been set on the northern frontier, had run from it when the Xiongnu came, and had been made a marquis for his trouble. The son was made a king instead, at twenty, over three commanderies and fifty-three cities.
The rebel was sixty-two when he rose, and had been put in his place by the man his father had failed. His father, the founder's elder brother, had been set on the northern frontier, had run from it when the Xiongnu came, and had been made a marquis for his trouble. The son was made a king instead, at twenty, over three commanderies and fifty-three cities.
Panel 03: Wu paid for it out of its own ground. Copper hills and seawater: runaways drawn in to mine and coin it, the sea boiled for salt, and no land tax taken from his own people for a generation. Men of note were rewarded year by year and every fugitive from another kingdom was refused back.
Wu paid for it out of its own ground. Copper hills and seawater: runaways drawn in to mine and coin it, the sea boiled for salt, and no land tax taken from his own people for a generation. Men of note were rewarded year by year and every fugitive from another kingdom was refused back.
Panel 04: The quarrel that made the war was a board game. The heir of Wu, lodging at court, played a betting game with the heir of Han; his tutors were Chu men, his manners had never been corrected; the imperial prince picked up the board and threw it, and killed him.
The quarrel that made the war was a board game. The heir of Wu, lodging at court, played a betting game with the heir of Han; his tutors were Chu men, his manners had never been corrected; the imperial prince picked up the board and threw it, and killed him.
Panel 05: Chao Cuo had told the late emperor for years that Wu could be cut, and had been listened to and not used. Under the new one he was Censor-in-chief, and he put the case in a form nobody could argue with: three of the great fiefs held half the empire.
Chao Cuo Cut him and he rises at once, and the wound is small. Do not cut him and he rises later, and it is greater.
Chao Cuo had told the late emperor for years that Wu could be cut, and had been listened to and not used. Under the new one he was Censor-in-chief, and he put the case in a form nobody could argue with: three of the great fiefs held half the empire.
Panel 06: The cuts came in pieces, one fief at a time, each with a charge attached: a commandery from Chu for the king's conduct during a mourning period, two commanderies from Wu, a commandery from Zhao, six counties from Jiaoxi for the titles it had been selling. Then an old man arrived from Yingchuan to tell his son what everyone in the empire was saying about him.
Chao Cuo It has to be done. If it is not, the Son of Heaven is not revered and the ancestral temples are not at rest.
The cuts came in pieces, one fief at a time, each with a charge attached: a commandery from Chu for the king's conduct during a mourning period, two commanderies from Wu, a commandery from Zhao, six counties from Jiaoxi for the titles it had been selling. Then an old man arrived from Yingchuan to tell his son what everyone in the empire was saying about him.
Panel 07: It was agreed by word of mouth, with no document. A Jiaoxi envoy of the king of Wu brought a proverb out of the streets — lick the chaff and you get to the rice — and an offer: strike west together, and the two lords will divide the empire.
It was agreed by word of mouth, with no document. A Jiaoxi envoy of the king of Wu brought a proverb out of the streets — lick the chaff and you get to the rice — and an offer: strike west together, and the two lords will divide the empire.
Panel 08: The old king emptied his kingdom into the field and told them so in the first person: he was sixty-two and would lead it himself, and his youngest son was fourteen and would go in the ranks ahead of them.
Liu Pi I am sixty-two years old and I will lead this in person. My youngest son is fourteen and goes before the men. Anyone between my age and his is called up.
The old king emptied his kingdom into the field and told them so in the first person: he was sixty-two and would lead it himself, and his youngest son was fourteen and would go in the ranks ahead of them.
Panel 09: The emperor was in his hall counting grain with his minister when the man he had warned about the king of Wu was fetched in. The answer he got was that Wu had no able men at all, and that the whole business was the work of runaway coiners — and that it would be over shortly.
Emperor Jing Let me see how far this can go. I am not so attached to one man that I will refuse the realm an apology.
The emperor was in his hall counting grain with his minister when the man he had warned about the king of Wu was fetched in. The answer he got was that Wu had no able men at all, and that the whole business was the work of runaway coiners — and that it would be over shortly.
Panel 10: Ten-odd days later the Commandant of the Capital sent for the Censor-in-chief with a carriage, on the pretext of a meeting. Chao Cuo did not know. Still dressed in his court robes, he was driven to the East Market and cut in half there.
Ten-odd days later the Commandant of the Capital sent for the Censor-in-chief with a carriage, on the pretext of a meeting. Chao Cuo did not know. Still dressed in his court robes, he was driven to the East Market and cut in half there.
Panel 11: A kinsman of the king of Wu was sent in first, to get him to kneel and take the pardon. Liu Pi laughed and said he was already the Emperor of the East, and kept the envoy in camp under guard, intending to make him serve or die.
A kinsman of the king of Wu was sent in first, to get him to kneel and take the pardon. Liu Pi laughed and said he was already the Emperor of the East, and kept the envoy in camp under guard, intending to make him serve or die.
Panel 12: An officer came back from the front with the news that ended the argument. The emperor asked whether the rebels had stopped when they heard that Cuo was dead. He said: no — and then told the emperor what the killing had actually done.
Deng Gong The king of Wu has been ready to rise for decades. The cutting of land is what he was angry about; killing Cuo is the name he gave it. His intent was never Cuo.
An officer came back from the front with the news that ended the argument. The emperor asked whether the rebels had stopped when they heard that Cuo was dead. He said: no — and then told the emperor what the killing had actually done.
Panel 13: He went out in a fast courier carriage, changed the road on the way because the enemy was rich and had long kept hirelings, and stopped at Luoyang to look for one famous fighting man. Finding him at home, he said, was half the campaign.
Zhou Yafu The men of Chu are swift and reckless; do not meet their edge. Give them Liang to chew on, cut their grain road, and they can be handled.
He went out in a fast courier carriage, changed the road on the way because the enemy was rich and had long kept hirelings, and stopped at Luoyang to look for one famous fighting man. Finding him at home, he said, was half the campaign.
Panel 14: The fief Yafu had promised to the rebels was the empire's richest, and its king was the emperor's own full brother and the empress dowager's favourite. His appeals arrived every day; then the emperor's order to relieve him arrived too. Yafu did not take the edict, sent light cavalry to seal off the grain road instead, and stayed where he was.
The fief Yafu had promised to the rebels was the empire's richest, and its king was the emperor's own full brother and the empress dowager's favourite. His appeals arrived every day; then the emperor's order to relieve him arrived too. Yafu did not take the edict, sent light cavalry to seal off the grain road instead, and stayed where he was.
Panel 15: The rebel side had two good plans and refused both. A general asked for fifty thousand to march up the rivers and come at the Wu Pass from behind, and was refused because the king would not put troops under anyone but his own family. Then a junior officer told him to stop taking towns and ride for the armoury and the granary.
The rebel side had two good plans and refused both. A general asked for fifty thousand to march up the rivers and come at the Wu Pass from behind, and was refused because the king would not put troops under anyone but his own family. Then a junior officer told him to stop taking towns and ride for the armoury and the granary.
Panel 16: At last the rebels came to the wall of the camp that had let them starve, and challenged for a battle every day. Nothing came out. At night a panic broke inside the Han camp, men ran on each other as far as the commander's own tent; he lay there and did not get up, and it steadied.
At last the rebels came to the wall of the camp that had let them starve, and challenged for a battle every day. Nothing came out. At night a panic broke inside the Han camp, men ran on each other as far as the commander's own tent; he lay there and did not get up, and it steadied.
Panel 17: The king of Wu rode out of his camp at night with his strong men and went south over the river to Dantu, and took refuge with the Yue of the east, who had perhaps ten thousand men of their own. The empire announced a price of a thousand catties of gold for the king's head and told those Yue what it would pay.
The king of Wu rode out of his camp at night with his strong men and went south over the river to Dantu, and took refuge with the Yue of the east, who had perhaps ten thousand men of their own. The empire announced a price of a thousand catties of gold for the king's head and told those Yue what it would pay.
Panel 18: The last king gave himself up bare-shouldered, sitting on straw and drinking water, and told the Han commander that Cuo's death had ended it and his army had gone home. The answer came from the son of the man who had handed over Mayi a generation before, and it was about a tally: you had no tiger tally and no order, and by that you show killing the minister was never what you wanted.
The last king gave himself up bare-shouldered, sitting on straw and drinking water, and told the Han commander that Cuo's death had ended it and his army had gone home. The answer came from the son of the man who had handed over Mayi a generation before, and it was about a tally: you had no tiger tally and no order, and by that you show killing the minister was never what you wanted.

In this episode

Six people carried 154 BCE: the minister whose plan outlived him, the commander who twice refused an order and was right both times, and the emperor who let them both be used.

Portrait of Liu Pi
Liu Pi劉濞
d. 154 BCE
King of Wu, sixty-two in 154 BCE, son of the founder's elder brother and therefore the founder's nephew. He had coins cast from his mountains and salt boiled from his sea, had not attended court for a generation, and lost a war that lasted three months.
Portrait of Chao Cuo
Chao Cuo晁錯
d. 154 BCE
Imperial adviser turned Censor-in-chief, called the bag of wit of the eastern palace while he served the crown prince. He wrote the plan to cut the fiefs back and was delivered to the block in his court robes to buy the rebels' withdrawal.
Portrait of Yuan Ang
Yuan Ang袁盎
d. 148 BCE
A former chancellor's rival and the one man the emperor had not let Chao Cuo destroy. He proposed the execution that was meant to end the war, carried the pardon to Wu, and was refused audience.
Portrait of Zhou Yafu
Zhou Yafu周亞夫
d. 143 BCE
Marquis of Jiang, commander-in-chief. The man whose camp the late emperor had been stopped outside for discipline. He let the rebels beat the empire's richest fief to pieces, cut their grain, and would not fight until they were starving.
Portrait of Liu Wu
Liu Wu劉武
d. 144 BCE
King of Liang, the emperor's full brother and the empire's richest prince. He held Suiyang through the siege, was deliberately abandoned while he held it, and spent the rest of his life getting even.
Portrait of Emperor Jing
188–141 BCE
Liu Qi, second emperor of Han, the prince who had killed the heir of Wu with a gaming board. He approved the strategy that won, gave way to the one that did not, and said afterwards that he regretted it.

Myth Check

The Ming romances of the Han dynasties, the stage plays drawn from them and the serials drawn from those are entertainment — and not a source. Where their famous scenes depart from the histories, we leave them out of the story and put them here.

The story you may know

Killing Chao Cuo very nearly ended the revolt, and only Zhou Yafu's stubbornness threw away a chance at peace.

What the sources say

The histories say the offer was refused on the spot and the war ran on unchanged. The emperor's own annal records the pardon and the restoration of the land, and then adds that Yuan Ang was sent to announce it and that it did not stop them. The king of Wu would not kneel to receive the edict, and had already declared himself Emperor of the East. Two men in the record say the killing achieved nothing at all: an officer returned from the front, and a Marquis of Gongguo to a king who had surrendered.

Shiji, juan 11 and 101; Hanshu, juan 5 and 49
The story you may know

The war of the Seven Kingdoms was a long and exhausting struggle that nearly brought the dynasty down.

What the sources say

It lasted a season. The rising is dated to a specific day, the jiazi day of the first month, and the Shiji's summary is that the armies attacked and held each other for three months and Wu and Chu were broken; the emperor's annal puts the pursuit of the king of Wu at Dantu in the same spring and the deaths of the six other kings before the summer. Zhao alone held out for ten months. The exhaustion in the record is not the war's but the settlement's: the empire's wealth grows in the decades after it.

Shiji, juan 106; Hanshu, juan 5; Zizhi Tongjian, scroll 16
The story you may know

The whole eastern half of the empire rose against Chang'an.

What the sources say

The coalition was seven kingdoms out of the many in the east, and two more never moved: the king of Qi regretted the agreement and poisoned himself, and the king of Jibei was held under guard by his own senior secretary and could not raise troops. Wu's own letter invited the kings of Huainan, Hengshan and Lujiang and an heir of old Changsha; none of them came. The Xiongnu, whom Zhao went to for help, sent nothing. The emperor's annal names the seven exactly, and they are the seven.

Shiji, juan 106; Hanshu, juan 5, Annals of Emperor Jing
The story you may know

The general who saved the dynasty died honoured, and the emperor he had served never forgot what he had done.

What the sources say

He was dismissed as chancellor, summoned to a banquet where a block of meat was set in front of him with no knife and no chopsticks, and told as he left that such a sulky man would not serve a young master. He was arrested over five hundred sets of store-made armour and shields his son had bought for his tomb and had gone unpaid on; asked why he was arming himself in the world below, he stopped answering, went hungry for five days and died vomiting blood. His king-of-Liang enemy had spent years telling the empress dowager against him, and had men kill the minister who had once been made chancellor in his place.

Shiji, juan 57; Hanshu, juan 40; Zizhi Tongjian, scroll 16
The story you may know

Zhou Yafu's end was fate: the physiognomist Xu Fu had read a line in his face that ran into his mouth and told him he would starve in nine years.

What the sources say

Both official histories carry that prediction, and Sima Qian closes the biography with the words Sure enough, the Marquis of Jiang starved to death — a life arranged backwards around an outcome. The same chapters say the plain facts: he was picked out of Zhou Bo's sons as the ablest and given the marquisate, and he died in the hands of jailers who wanted a confession he would not give. Nothing in the accounts of 154 BCE requires the diviner, and the campaign's decisions were his own.

Shiji, juan 57; Hanshu, juan 40

Sources

Every caption and quotation in this episode traces to one of these. Where scholars disagree, the panel says so.

Next

The fiefs were cut back, the treasury filled, and the empire turned its face outward — an officer volunteered for a ride of thirteen years: Episode 4 · The Road Bored Open (Longxi to the Oxus, 138 BCE). The treasury that survived that war is what paid for the road west. Or back to the Han line, or meet the cast.