Bamboo Scroll竹簡 Ep. 10 · The Gates at Dawn
At dawn armoured soldiers haul the great gates of Luoyang shut while in the distance an imperial procession with banners moves away toward the mound tombs on the plain, 249 CE
Bamboo Scroll · Three Kingdoms · Episode 10

The Gates at Dawn

Luoyang, 249 CE — The emperor rode out to pray at the tombs; behind him an old man who had been dying for two years closed the gates of the capital — by nightfall the regent had surrendered, and within ten days he was dead.
16 panels~6 min read free to readevery line sourced
Panel 01: Spring, 249 CE. The emperor of Wei rode out of his capital to honour the tombs of his house. Behind him, in the city he had left, an old man who had been dying for two years was putting on armour. This is the story of a coup, not a battle: no armies met, and one dynasty changed hands anyway.
Spring, 249 CE. The emperor of Wei rode out of his capital to honour the tombs of his house. Behind him, in the city he had left, an old man who had been dying for two years was putting on armour. This is the story of a coup, not a battle: no armies met, and one dynasty changed hands anyway.
Panel 02: It began eight years earlier. In 239 the emperor Cao Rui died and left his eight-year-old heir Cao Fang to two regents: Cao Shuang, kinsman of the imperial house, and Sima Yi, the old commander of the western wars. They did not share for long. Cao Shuang moved Sima Yi from the command of the armies to the higher, emptier seat of Grand Tutor — and the court was his.
It began eight years earlier. In 239 the emperor Cao Rui died and left his eight-year-old heir Cao Fang to two regents: Cao Shuang, kinsman of the imperial house, and Sima Yi, the old commander of the western wars. They did not share for long. Cao Shuang moved Sima Yi from the command of the armies to the higher, emptier seat of Grand Tutor — and the court was his.
Panel 03: For years Cao Shuang held the court through his brothers and his favourites — He Yan, Deng Yang, Ding Mi, Bi Gui, Li Sheng. The record against him is heavy: the late emperor's carriages and instruments used for his own pleasure, his banquets running deep into the night.
For years Cao Shuang held the court through his brothers and his favourites — He Yan, Deng Yang, Ding Mi, Bi Gui, Li Sheng. The record against him is heavy: the late emperor's carriages and instruments used for his own pleasure, his banquets running deep into the night.
Panel 04: In 247 Sima Yi claimed illness and withdrew from affairs. When Cao Shuang's man Li Sheng came to take leave before a provincial posting, the old man had two maidservants hold him up, let porridge run from his mouth down his chest, and spoke only of death and of his two sons. Li Sheng went back and reported: he is finished.
In 247 Sima Yi claimed illness and withdrew from affairs. When Cao Shuang's man Li Sheng came to take leave before a provincial posting, the old man had two maidservants hold him up, let porridge run from his mouth down his chest, and spoke only of death and of his two sons. Li Sheng went back and reported: he is finished.
Panel 05: On the day jiawu of the first month of 249 the emperor Cao Fang rode out of Luoyang to visit the Gaoping Tombs, the imperial burial ground south of the city along the Luo river. Cao Shuang and his brothers rode with him — and so did almost everyone who mattered.
On the day jiawu of the first month of 249 the emperor Cao Fang rode out of Luoyang to visit the Gaoping Tombs, the imperial burial ground south of the city along the Luo river. Cao Shuang and his brothers rode with him — and so did almost everyone who mattered.
Panel 06: In the city, the sick man rose. Sima Yi put on armour. His elder son Sima Shi brought out the men he had been quietly gathering: three thousand sworn retainers, all ready to die, whose existence the court had never suspected.
In the city, the sick man rose. Sima Yi put on armour. His elder son Sima Shi brought out the men he had been quietly gathering: three thousand sworn retainers, all ready to die, whose existence the court had never suspected.
Panel 07: First, the paper. Sima Yi laid a memorial before the Empress Dowager Guo listing Cao Shuang's offences against the throne and the orphan's trust, and asked for his removal. The edict came down: Cao Shuang was stripped of office.
First, the paper. Sima Yi laid a memorial before the Empress Dowager Guo listing Cao Shuang's offences against the throne and the orphan's trust, and asked for his removal. The edict came down: Cao Shuang was stripped of office.
Panel 08: Then, the gates. Luoyang's gates were closed. Sima Yi's men seized the armouries and the palaces, and a column went out to hold the floating bridge over the Luo river. No one of consequence was left inside the city to fight; the capital changed hands without a battle.
Then, the gates. Luoyang's gates were closed. Sima Yi's men seized the armouries and the palaces, and a column went out to hold the floating bridge over the Luo river. No one of consequence was left inside the city to fight; the capital changed hands without a battle.
Panel 09: The old commander said he wanted no war, only his office back. When Cao Shuang's man Zhang Dang came to sound his intent, Sima Yi sent him home with the offer: the regent loses no more than office. Then he pointed at the river Luo itself and swore it.
Sima Yi Say to the regent: he loses no more than office. Nothing further.
The old commander said he wanted no war, only his office back. When Cao Shuang's man Zhang Dang came to sound his intent, Sima Yi sent him home with the offer: the regent loses no more than office. Then he pointed at the river Luo itself and swore it.
Panel 10: Not everyone had stayed in the city. Huan Fan rode out through the gates with the emperor's seal and brought the one bold counsel to the camp at the tombs: carry the Son of Heaven to Xuchang, call on the armies of every province — who will dare refuse the emperor? Cao Shuang listened, and could not decide.
Not everyone had stayed in the city. Huan Fan rode out through the gates with the emperor's seal and brought the one bold counsel to the camp at the tombs: carry the Son of Heaven to Xuchang, call on the armies of every province — who will dare refuse the emperor? Cao Shuang listened, and could not decide.
Panel 11: The night went by over a dying fire. At last Cao Shuang said: even so, I can still be a wealthy marquis. Old Huan Fan wept: Cao Zidan was a good man, but his sons are pigs and donkeys. In the morning the answer went back to the city: he would yield.
The night went by over a dying fire. At last Cao Shuang said: even so, I can still be a wealthy marquis. Old Huan Fan wept: Cao Zidan was a good man, but his sons are pigs and donkeys. In the morning the answer went back to the city: he would yield.
Panel 12: Cao Shuang sent up the emperor's seal and ribbons, dismissed his followers, and came back to Luoyang to live under guard in his own mansion. On the road he was still telling himself about the marquisate. The gates that had shut behind him now shut around him.
Cao Shuang sent up the emperor's seal and ribbons, dismissed his followers, and came back to Luoyang to live under guard in his own mansion. On the road he was still telling himself about the marquisate. The gates that had shut behind him now shut around him.
Panel 13: Ten days had not passed when an impeachment of great treason came before the throne, and the law officers took the case. Cao Shuang, his brothers Cao Xi and Cao Xun, and his faction — He Yan, Deng Yang, Ding Mi, Bi Gui, and Huan Fan who had carried the seal — were executed, and their three branches of kin with them.
Ten days had not passed when an impeachment of great treason came before the throne, and the law officers took the case. Cao Shuang, his brothers Cao Xi and Cao Xun, and his faction — He Yan, Deng Yang, Ding Mi, Bi Gui, and Huan Fan who had carried the seal — were executed, and their three branches of kin with them.
Panel 14: One man had sworn the oath that bought the surrender, and he did not live with it. Jiang Ji, whose letter had gone into the camp promising no more than loss of office, asked Sima Yi to keep faith, could not prevail, and died of remorse within months.
One man had sworn the oath that bought the surrender, and he did not live with it. Jiang Ji, whose letter had gone into the camp promising no more than loss of office, asked Sima Yi to keep faith, could not prevail, and died of remorse within months.
Panel 15: The emperor kept his throne — that was the whole difference from the day before. Sima Yi declined the chancellorship and the Nine Bestowals offered him, and governed from a mat below the dais. Every memorial, every appointment, every guard went through his hands first.
The emperor kept his throne — that was the whole difference from the day before. Sima Yi declined the chancellorship and the Nine Bestowals offered him, and governed from a mat below the dais. Every memorial, every appointment, every guard went through his hands first.
Panel 16: Sima Yi had two years left. He died in 251 and his sons ruled after him, Sima Shi and then Sima Zhao; in 254 Cao Fang was deposed, in 263 Shu fell, and in 265 Sima Yi's grandson took the throne himself and named the new dynasty Jin. The coup at the Gaoping Tombs was not a battle, but it was the decisive move: after that morning, Wei belonged to the Sima family.
Sima Yi had two years left. He died in 251 and his sons ruled after him, Sima Shi and then Sima Zhao; in 254 Cao Fang was deposed, in 263 Shu fell, and in 265 Sima Yi's grandson took the throne himself and named the new dynasty Jin. The coup at the Gaoping Tombs was not a battle, but it was the decisive move: after that morning, Wei belonged to the Sima family.

In this episode

The people who carried this year. The sources disagree about almost everything else.

Portrait of Sima Yi
Sima Yi司馬懿
179–251 CE
Regent of Wei, demoted to the empty seat of Grand Tutor. Feigned illness for two years, rose in a single morning, took the capital without a fight and broke his oath within ten days. Died two years later with his house ruling in his place.
Portrait of Cao Shuang
d. 249 CE
Co-regent and kinsman of the imperial house. Held the court through his brothers and favourites, pushed Sima Yi aside, and rode out of the city on the morning that mattered. Surrendered on a promise of safety; executed with his faction ten days later.
Portrait of Cao Fang
Cao Fang曹芳
c. 231–274 CE
Emperor of Wei from the age of eight. Rode out to the Gaoping Tombs and rode back a guest in his own palace; deposed by the Sima house in 254, he died in retirement in 274.
Portrait of Jiang Ji
Jiang Ji蔣濟
d. 249 CE
Veteran minister whose name gave weight to an oath. His letter to the camp promised Cao Shuang no more than the loss of office; he watched the promise break, and died of remorse within months.
Portrait of Sima Shi
Sima Shi司馬師
208–255 CE
Sima Yi's elder son. Quietly gathered three thousand sworn retainers who answered when the gates closed; after his father's death he ruled Wei in all but name.

Myth Check

The novel Romance of the Three Kingdoms is a masterpiece — and not a source. Where its famous scenes depart from the histories, we leave them out of the story and put them here.

The story you may know

The Gaoping Tombs was a battle — armies meeting outside Luoyang.

What the sources say

No engagement is recorded anywhere. The coup was won by paperwork and gates: an edict from the Empress Dowager, the city gates closed, the armouries seized, and an envoy's promise. The only violence came afterwards, at the executions. It was a seizure of the capital, not a battle in the field.

Jin shu, Annals of Emperor Xuan; Sanguozhi, Wei shu 9; Zizhi Tongjian, scroll 75
The story you may know

Sima Yi swore Cao Shuang's safety by the river Luo — and kept his word.

What the sources say

The oath is recorded, and it was broken within ten days: Cao Shuang and his faction were charged with great treason and executed with all three branches of their kin. The promise was the instrument of the surrender, not its terms.

Sanguozhi, Wei shu 9, Biography of Cao Shuang; Jin shu, Annals of Emperor Xuan; Zizhi Tongjian, scroll 75
The story you may know

Sima Yi played the invalid for decades — the patient lifelong long-con of legend.

What the sources say

The record is narrower and stranger: he served as co-regent and commander from 239 to 247 — leading Wei's defence against Shu's invasion of 243–244 — then claimed illness from 247, staged it for Li Sheng in 248, and struck in 249. Two years of performance, not twenty; and since he died within two years of the coup, some of the illness may have been real. The sources want it read as pure cunning.

Jin shu, Annals of Emperor Xuan; Wei shu, in Pei Songzhi's commentary; Sanguozhi, Wei shu 4
The story you may know

The coup was one old man's solo stroke.

What the sources say

It was a family conspiracy with an official face: the Jin shu annals of Emperor Jing record Sima Shi's three thousand secretly gathered retainers, Sima Zhao was in the plot, the Empress Dowager's edict gave it legality, and ministers like Jiang Ji carried its promises to the camp.

Jin shu, Annals of Emperor Jing and Emperor Xuan; Zizhi Tongjian, scroll 75
The story you may know

Wei fell that day — 249 ended the Cao dynasty.

What the sources say

Cao Fang remained emperor five more years and was deposed in 254; his successors reigned until 265, when Sima Yi's grandson took the throne by the abdication ritual and named the dynasty Jin. The coup did not end Wei; it made the ending certain.

Sanguozhi, Wei shu 4, Annals of the Three Young Emperors; Jin shu, Annals of Emperor Wu

Sources

Every caption and quotation in this episode traces to one of these. Where scholars disagree, the panel says so.

Next

Before this: Episode 9 · The Bait at Shiting (Shiting, 228 CE). Next: Episode 11 · The Gate and the Trackless Road (Chengdu, 263 CE). Or meet the cast, or read the chronology of the age.