Chinese Literature
Ink-wash painting of the Liangshan marsh at dawn: a palisade stronghold with unmarked banners, reed beds and boats on still water.

Reading note I · The ending

How does Water Margin end?

水滸傳結局

The outlaws win every campaign they are sent on and are destroyed by the reward. The hundred and eight who took the marsh are counted in the dozens by the end, and the chief dies of an honour the court sent him — the novel's whole argument, settled in two chapters.

The toll
The amnesty holds only as long as the court needs them. After the Liao campaign comes Fang La (ch. 110–119), and the southern war kills the great majority of the 108 — by the usual count fewer than thirty return to the capital for reward.
Song Jiang
Poisoned wine, sent as an honour, chapter 120. Knowing Li Kui will rebel and ruin the names, he calls him to the grave-side and gives him the same cup.
The loyal four
Wu Yong and Hua Rong hang themselves at Song Jiang's tomb; Li Kui dies of the wine; the four are buried together at Liaoerwa.
The ones who live
Lu Zhishen attains nirvana at the Qiantang tide (ch. 119); the one-armed Wu Song lives to eighty at Liuhe temple; Lin Chong, paralysed, dies in Wu Song's care.

The last forty chapters, compressed 後段

ChaptersWhat happensWhere the 108 stand
82The amnesty is granted; the outlaws become the court's army108 alive, sworn at the stone tablet of ch. 71
83–89The Liao campaign — wonLosses begin, but the corps is still itself
110–119The Fang La campaign — won, and ruinousThe majority of the 108 fall in the south; the roster's fate column is mostly written here
120Rewards, wine, burials; the emperor dreams, and a temple is builtFewer than 30 return; the chief is dead by the gift

The five endings people ask about 五種結局

StarFateChapters
Song Jiangpoisoned by court wine sent as an honour; buried at Liaoerwa with the loyal dead120
Lu Zhishenhears the Qiantang tide, baths, sits, and attains nirvana — the best death the book gives anyone119
Wu Songloses an arm in the last battle, declines all reward, and lives to eighty as a monk at Liuhe temple117, 119
Lin Chongparalysed by illness after the campaigns, carried for half a year by Wu Song, dies in his care119
Wu Yong and Hua Ronghang themselves together at Song Jiang's tomb — the final entry in the book's account of loyalty120

Every row can be checked against the roster table on this site's hub page, which carries the same fates chapter by chapter.

Why the novel ends this way 為何如此

The ending is not a betrayal of the outlaws; it is the bill for their own highest wish. From the stone tablet of chapter 71 onward, what all one hundred and eight want — stated in their own oath — is amnesty: to be folded back into the order that hunted them. The court grants exactly that, and uses it. Every campaign is loyal work, the deaths in the south are loyal deaths, and the wine is a reward — the novel simply refuses to let the loyalty pay any other way.

That is why the frame closes with an emperor who dreams the truth and builds a temple: the book lets heaven clear their names and the court keep the murders, in the same gesture. The reader who finishes angry at the court has read it right; the reader who notices that the outlaws asked for this has read it twice.

Chapter attributions follow the 120-chapter text. The reading of the amnesty as the outlaws' own wish turned against them is this site's.

Where these figures come from 出處